Moral dilemmas
Sivan Kutty, of 75 years of age lives, in Hyderabad. He is a retired man and spends his wakeful hours adding up the income from his various investments, and doing a five-kilometer sprightly walk followed by a short jog, to keep the heart pumping and the arteries clean. At sundown he sits before the TV with a carefully measured glass of Scotch whisky (it has been said of him that his price is but a bottle of IMFL), getting up only once to serve himself a treasured second drink. All through his life he has lived apart from his extended family, only on rare occasions meeting any member of the family. It is during these moments that his eyes become glassy, mulling over his achievements and failures of the past and often faced with a moral dilemma, whether to get into the act and save the souls of his wayward relatives of the younger generation or not? Some times these thoughts become too strong for him to dismiss them lightly and cause another dilemma, whether to pour out another valuable drink or not? But soon his accountant’s instinct tells him what it would cost and he dismisses the rabid idea and walks off to the dinner table.
Sivan Kutty was an accountant for 30 years in a British company. He joined the company in his early twenties, after failing to qualify as a chartered accountant in UK. He married a Scottish girl in UK and moved to India in early sixties to work as an accountant in the company’s Hyderabad plant. In the early days life was a struggle for him, having produced two children in quick succession and needing to maintain the wife of foreign origin. Life being such a struggle, he firmly declined when his mother asked him to send her a few hundred rupees for her maintenance every month (his mother, a wealthy woman, was now a little short of money as she had divided and given all her family money away to her children – Sivan Kutty and his siblings, of which you are to meet the sisters Janu and Sita soon).
Being free of such encumbrances, Sivan Kutty worked steadily and cultivated influential people for which his wife of foreign origin was an asset. Being an accountant he knew very well that a price has to be paid for every gain. If you knew the price and prepared to pay it, yes the gain is yours! In those days there was no moral dilemma! And Sivan Kutty crawled steadily up the corporate ladder to become a director by the time he retired with a comfortable savings and retirement benefits.
One day, his family ties got the better of his usual thrift and Sivan Kutty decided to have a third drink and also made the momentous decision to save the souls of his wayward younger generation and dialed the number of his dear sister Sita (who he had hated for many years but had now become an asset on his moral balance sheet) in Chennai. Sivan Kutty announced the decision to Save the life of their elder sister Janu who was living with her son Venu in Coimbatore………. Of Janu’s daughter Parvathy and her relatives I have written in one of my earlier posting “Bitching! Bitching!! All the way!”
Janu, Parvathy’s mother, is 85 years old, and was widowed over 30 years ago. She has lived the best part of these 30years with Parvathy in Mumbai or Venu in Coimbatore, as she felt unable to live on her own. The family property was sold and unlike Janu and her siblings, who had taken their individual shares from their widowed mother without a pang of regret, Parvathy and her brothers invested their shares of the family property for Janu’s use. Because of Parvathy’s thrift and resourcefulness Janu’s investments had grown sizeable in 30 years.
For Janu is lavish in her ways, being the daughter of a wealthy man and then the wife of a wealthy man. Janu is also easy to manipulate and financially illiterate. Despite this, Janu has been able to live a fairly lavish life as a widow, because she has lived with and been supported by her daughter or son, spending the income from the family property mostly on her lavish ways.
This situation has caused a dilemma for Janu’s sister Sita who I have in my earlier post referred to as Parvathy’s “wicked aunty.” Sita, who is also lavish like her sister, has frittered away her share of the family property, and continues to live lavishly on the largesse of her long-suffering sons.
But Sita thought that it was her bounden duty to enquire about (or interfere with) the welfare of her widowed sister and put several questions to Janu – innocent talk at first, acknowledging her good fortune to have such good daughter and son and daughter-in-law. Over a period of time, Sita’s questions became loaded, giving hints to Janu that she could certainly lead a better life (like herself) and not be a slave of her children (who ensured that Janu did not fritter away the family money like Sita had done). She incited Janu to take charge of her own affairs and handle her financial matters herself.
Slowly Janu, whose intelligence was below average even in her youth started to believe that her Daughter-in-law was not giving enough respect and attention. She became moody and querulous often and causing strained relationship with her son Venu, d-in-law, their children and Parvathy too. Parvathy always sympathized with Venu and his wife who were doing their utmost to make Janu’s life as comfortable as possible but Janu remained disgruntled all the time. Cunningly incited by Sita, Janu started attacking her son and d-in-law and daughter Parvathy too.
A little history first. Though it was very difficult for Parvathy to accommodate Janu in her small flat in Mumbai, Janu stayed with Parvathy for a good part of the first 15 years after her husband died. After Parvathy’s husband retired from service and her two daughters got married, Parvathy and her husband shifted to a bigger house in Bangalore. Due to health problems and advancing age both Parvathy and her husband were not in a position to keep Janu any more. So Janu has been staying with Venu in Coimbatore for the past 15 years.
Sita had convinced Janu that her daughter will not keep her because her husband may not want her in the house and that earlier they accommodated her in their small flat in Mumbai because they wanted to use her money. Janu was always used to be treated with kid gloves because her late husband was a highly respected person and she basked in his glory. Janu (at 85!) became emboldened by Sita’s machinations to tell her son that she wanted to live separately - which was not feasible, given her meager income and lavish life style.
This was the moment Sita waited for and when Sivan Kutty phoned her from Hyderabad she did a buck and wing and said to herself “Now the fun will start. The waiting was not for nothing!!” Sita immediately phoned Parvathy’s sis-in-law in Singapore (who hated Parvathy from the time Parvathy’s brother married her) and sang to her that the time has come to teach Parvathy a lesson. Soon the plan was unfolded – Janu was to quarrel with Venu and his wife and ask Parvathy to put her up in her house in Bangalore, knowing well that she has expressed her inability to do so.
Next Sivan Kutty and Sita would bring Janu to Bangalore under some pretext and accommodate her in a separate home. Then they would tell Parvathy that it was her moral duty to accommodate her poor mother who was living alone and Parvathy (worried about what others would say) would be forced to take her in. If Parvathy refused, they would ask her to transfer the capital amount of the family money which was held in trust by Parvathy to Janu under the pretext that Janu needed the money to run her separate house. Then it was just a matter of time before they could prey on simpleton Janu and scoot with the money!
A grand plan, but Parvathy stood strong and asked Sivan Kutty and others who engineered the whole plan to go to hell and look after her themselves. They threatened Parvathy with legal action to get the money from her. Parvathy did not budge. Nothing happened. By then, Sivan Kutty and Sita were getting fed up with Janu’s constant complaints and lavish ways. Quickly they took Janu back to Venu’s house in Coimbatore.
Moral of the story is that when you do not have any morals to speak of, you should not preach. Neither Sivan Kutty nor Sita ever bothered to look after their parents in their old age when they were in need and suffering but they had to preach ‘duty’ and ‘moral obligations’ to Parvathy who without anyone’s prompting had done her duties by her parents and others. But when pushed to a corner by scheming relatives she stood by her convictions daring them to take whatever action they wanted to take, and not buckling under pressure or threats.

